SPN - Someone Else's Life, part 1
Oct. 21st, 2019 07:46 pmSam doesn't ask her to go with him.
When all the shouting is finished and all the doors have been slammed, when John has handed down the ultimatum which made Sam storm out of the house they're squatting in, when her father has smashed the first of the bottles he's crawling into against his bedroom wall, Dee puts the overturned chairs back on their feet and drives her baby brother to the bus station.
He's made it nearly two miles in twenty minutes, the long-legged freak, but he doesn't hesitate to get in when the Impala rolls up next to him. The car is silent as Sam decides what he wants to say. Dee can feel his brain working, weighing words and how they fit together and discarding sentence after sentence that won't get him what he wants. She knows, she always knows, what he wants.
But he doesn't work up the courage to say it, which she's glad for, because neither of them is completely sure who she'd choose if it came down to it and neither of them wants to find out that the answer is "John" after all. She's a coward when it comes to her father and Sam's a coward when it comes to her so here they sit in the Impala, parked across from the bus station, not asking each other not to leave.
He doesn't have to say it for her to know that it's an option, that he'd love her to come with him. It should be an easy choice, in his mind. Yes or no, stay or go, Sam or John. Stick with the drunken, obsessive, neglectful father or follow the beloved baby brother to sunny California and all the freedoms it represents. It's simple, to Sam, because Sam doesn't understand. Why she never left John, why she gave up on normality and didn't graduate high school. What it's like to watch your house burn down with your brother in your arms and your mother still inside. What it's like to look at John and see the man he used to be.
He does understand that it isn't an easy choice, though. Enough not to ask her to make it.
She tucks her box of emergency cash into his bag and tells him to call Bobby Singer if he needs a loan and Pastor Jim if he needs advice and doesn't tell him to call her if he needs her because it'll break her heart if he doesn't. She checks that he has a satisfactory supply of salt, holy water, M&Ms. She fusses over the guns he didn't pack and inventories the knives he did.
He doesn't say a word until he's out of the car and about to cross the road, at which point he leans in her open window to kiss her cheek and mutter "I love you" before taking off without giving her the chance to recover enough from the shock of that to say anything back. She figures that's a pretty clear indication that he's not really looking for a response, but says "You too" to his retreating back anyway. She has no idea if he hears her.
It's still dark out when he walks into the building and she's not going anywhere until she sees him get on the damn bus, because he doesn't stop being her responsibility when he's walking away from her. She sits for hours in the Impala and plays the radio instead of her cassettes because she doesn't want her music tainted by association with this mess. She wonders if she's waiting to make sure he gets on the bus safely or to make sure that he knows he doesn't have to get on the bus at all, and can't come up with an answer that feels honest.
Buses start showing up and leaving again but none of them are Sam's. The bus to California turns up with the dawn, which is some symbolic bullshit, and when he comes out of the station and catches sight of her still parked across the road she realises that she doesn't want to find out what he'd choose either, starts the engine and starts moving before he can pick a direction to walk in.
She can't stop herself from glancing in the mirror when she pulls away, taking in the defeated set of Sam's shoulders and the way he wraps his arms around himself. He looks very alone.
She wonders about all the things he decided not to say.
It's good that he didn't ask, though, really it is.
She could never follow him to Stanford.
She turns up on his doorstep all of three months later.
This is an AU where Deanna follows Sam to Stanford. I was originally going to write them having a conversation before he left, but I couldn't make it work — there was no way I could fit in everything I wanted Sam to say to her. Then I realised that there was probably nothing he could say that she hadn't already thought of anyway. So I thought that a good format for this fic might be a series of segments, each one starting with something Sam might have said to her, as she tries to figure out what it is she wants & makes her way to California.